Kohler Elliston vs. Cimarron Toilet

Every homeowner needs a spectacular functional commode to complete their bathroom. A bathroom is a special place where you need to relax and unwind after a long tiring day to take a relaxing bath and do your other business. Furthermore, investing in the right toilet will elevate the overall value of your property if you’re looking forward to staging it for the real estate market. So, for that reason, if you want to remodel your bathroom or simply looking for a new commode for your new home, consider investing in a modern-day toilet design from a reputable brand in the industry, such as Kohler. Here is a detailed comparison between the Kohler Elliston vs. Cimarron toilet to help you make an informed buying decision.

Kohler Elliston Comfort Height 2 Piece Elongated Toilet

To evaluate the Kohler Elliston toilet, we will look at different features such as the design, affordability, material, water efficiency, flushing technology, and more. The Elliston is a two-piece toilet with durable vitreous china construction. It has a high seat that allows people to sit comfortably and a long bowl that provides extra space. Therefore, larger individuals will find this unit more comfortable than round-shaped commodes.

Furthermore, it’s much easier to use as you can sit down and get up without too much difficulty. Water efficiency is a key feature for septic systems to be environmentally friendly. The Ellison toilet from Kohler delivers just that. Its design also makes it highly energy efficient, and this toilet uses just 1.28 GPF to flush the toilet bowl, which is a big plus. This is ideal in areas where water is scarce; every drop of water matters. Ellison is equipped with the latest technology that uses high-pressure water to flush the toilet bowl and flush the tank with no need to use additional lines.

It is very convenient to use as it pushes water from a high-pressure water tank into the toilet bowl and then flushes the whole toilet bowl with one touch. It is also convenient to use, as the lever is located on the left side, so it is easy to use even when sitting down. This toilet has everything included but is missing the necessary supply line. It contains the bowl, the tank, the seat, the wax ring, and the bolts. The lines are available from anywhere, are of different lengths, and can be bought anytime. Kohler Elliston is also affordable. This makes it the best option for many people.


Key Features

  • Weighs 79.13 Pounds
  • White in color
  • Two-piece design
  • Left-hand Polished Chrome trip lever
  • Made from vitreous China
  • WaterSense certified
  • Elongated in shape
  • Comfort height
  • Consumes 1.28 GPF
  • Unit measures 30 x 16.75 x 30.5 inches
  • AquaPiston Flushing technology
  • 1-year limited warranty

Pros of Kohler Elliston Toilet

  • Single-flush gravity uses the force of gravity
  • Two-bolt installation
  • Affordable
  • Very comfortable bowl
  • Standard 12″ (305 mm) rough-in.
  • It’s a great water-saving toilet
  • The very sturdy vitreous china construction
  • An elongated shape that provides extra sitting space
  • Come with a five-class flushing technology that is very powerful
  • It has a sleek, clean style that complements any décor
  • Its chair-height seating offers accessibility and extra comfort

Cons of Kohler Elliston

  • The commode order doesn’t include a supply line.

Kohler K-3589-0 Cimarron Comfort Height Elongated Toilet

We’ll discuss some of the most crucial features of the Kohler K-3589-0 Cimarron commode. Cimarron toilets are built from durable vitreous china material and have glass-like protection. Every home needs a toilet that is easy to use, and the Cimarron toilet is one of them. It’s designed with a sitting height that is perfect for seniors to sit down and stand up while using the bathroom easily. Remember, seniors and people with mobility issues may find round-shaped toilets quite challenging.

This toilet is easy to install; just ensure that you measure your existing toilet carefully before heading to the market. The DryLock installation of the toilet to a wall is easy to do, and it will not cause any problems if something leaks from the bowl.

If you want to invest in this toilet, you should purchase separate toilet seats, water supply lines, and wax rings. These items are not included in the box, but they are available if you buy them individually. Cimarron flushes waste very efficiently at 1.6GPF, which is very efficient in terms of water usage. It’s also covered by a one-year parts warranty!

Although Kohler K-3589-0 Cimarron uses a bit more water than the Kohler Elliston Comfort Height, the powerful flushing system on this toilet is incredibly effective. AquaPiston provides a huge force that pushes water with immense force down the rim of the toilet bowl, so it can remove large solid wastes quickly. The Cimarron flushing system is highly efficient, and virtually no clogs will occur down the road. While the Cimarron toilet is priced more, the features that are packed into it make it one of the most desired Kohler toilets.


Key Features

  • Two-piece design
  • Made from vitreous China
  • Floor Mounted style
  • White in color
  • Weighs 1 Pound
  • WaterSense certified
  • Elongated in shape
  • Unit measures 28.75 x 17.62 x 30.75 inches
  • Comfort height
  • Consumes 1.6 Gallons per Flush
  • Gravity flush toilet
  • Left-hand lever position
  • Five-class flush technology
  • One-year limited warranty

Pros of Kohler K-3589-0 Cimarron

  • Come with AquaPiston flushing technology that is very powerful
  • Water-efficient at 1.68 GPF
  • The durable construction of vitreous china
  • DryLock installation feature that prevents leaks
  • The elongated shape of the toilet bowl is great for seniors and people with mobility concerns.
  • Easy to install.

Cons of Kohler K-3589-0 Cimarron

  • The seat and supply line are not included in the commode order.

Kohler Elliston vs. Cimarron Toilet Feature Comparisons

There are some similarities and differences between the two toilets. When comparing the Kohler Elliston Toilet and the Cimarron Toilet side by side, we discovered the following similarities and differences:

Similarities Between Kohler Elliston and Cimarron Toilets

There are certain features common with nearly every toilet made by Kohler. For example, the Cimarron and Elliston are two-piece toilets that are made from durable vitreous china materials like porcelain.

Their seats are very comfy, and the height of the toilet bowl is exactly like that of a normal sitting chair. So, elderly people and people with disabilities can sit and get up easily. The extra-long shape of the bowl provides more comfortable seating.

We also realized that the two toilets are available in white colors and are qualified to be water-efficient units (both are WaterSense certified). Therefore, you don’t need to worry about an exaggerated water bill once you install either of the two units in your bathroom.

Differences Between Kohler Elliston and Cimarron Toilets

The water consumption differences that separate the Cimarron and Elliston come from the different ways that they use water. Elliston uses 1.28 gallons per flush (GPF) and is a good water-saving toilet. Although the Cimarron consumes 1.68 GPF, it’s still water-efficient compared to the typical traditional bathrooms that you may find in some homes or older commercial buildings.

When we compare the flushing system of both toilets, the Cimarron is a step ahead with its clog-free flushing system; it flushes properly. This is because it uses an AquaPiston flush valve instead of a traditional flush valve. While the Elliston flushing technology is not as efficient as the Cimarron option, it’s not a single flush, and you might need to invest in some additional flushing system.

If you consider the affordability, it is clear that the Cimarron is more expensive than its Elliston counterpart. In general, if you want a reasonably priced toilet with great features, then the Kohler Elliston is a great pick. You shouldn’t worry so much about the flushing technology of this unit because it’s actually above average compared to the other units you may come across on the market. On the other hand, if you’re looking for a toilet with robust clog-free-flushing performance and don’t mind the price tag, then the Cimarron is your perfect choice.


What are the measurements of a comfort height commode?

Comfort height is usually the same as that of a regular chair in your home or office. The height should be around 17 to 19 inches.

Do the two toilet designs have a slow-close seat?

It’s important to note that the Cimarron doesn’t come with a toilet seat. While the Elliston comes with a seat, it isn’t a soft-close toilet seat.

Does the Elliston’s seat have the quick-release feature?

Yes. It has this feature which makes it very easy to clean.

Are these toilets water-efficient?

Yes. While the Elliston consumes 1.28 GPF, the Cimarron consumes 1.68 GPF, which are both great compared to their traditional counterparts that can consume up to 3 gallons of water per flush.

The Verdict

Kohler toilet makers produce some of the best models for commercial and residential settings. So, if you’re looking for a high-end toilet model to transform the look and feel of your bathroom, these two toilet options have you covered. The quality and durability of these toilets are timeless and come packed with unique features you might not find in other toilets. We’ve outlined some distinctive features between the two commodes to help buyers make informed decisions and avoid incurring substantial losses down the road.


Leave a Reply