Is a Tile Shower the Best Option for Your Bathroom?

9 Reasons Not to Build a Tile Shower (and What to Consider Instead)

Tile showers are a ubiquitous feature in bathrooms, gracing the pages of design magazines and gracing countless homes with their timeless elegance. With endless design possibilities and a reputation for durability, it’s easy to understand their enduring popularity. However, before you get swept away by the allure of handcrafted mosaics or meticulously laid subway tiles, it’s crucial to consider the potential downsides.

While undeniably beautiful, tile showers come with challenges that might not be ideal for every homeowner. Here are 9 reasons why a tile shower might not be the best option for your bathroom, along with alternative solutions to ponder:

1. The Mold and Mildew Menace

Grout, the seemingly innocuous partner to tile, harbors a dark secret: it’s a breeding ground for mold and mildew. Its porous nature acts like a sponge, readily absorbing the constant moisture present in a shower environment. This creates a prime habitat for these unwelcome guests, leading to unsightly black streaks, musty odors, and potential health concerns. While regular cleaning and sealing with a high-quality grout sealer can help mitigate this issue, it requires consistent vigilance.  For busy homeowners or those with mobility limitations, the constant battle against mold can become a frustrating and time-consuming chore.

1 9

Alternative Solutions

If the thought of constant scrubbing and battling mold growth gives you pause, consider alternative shower wall materials. Solid surface materials like acrylic or composite panels offer a non-porous surface that resists mold and mildew growth. Additionally, some tile manufacturers offer grout with built-in mold and mildew protection, reducing the frequency of resealing.  Another option is to minimize grout lines altogether by opting for larger format tiles that require less grout overall.

2. Leaky Troubles: A Shower Nightmare

One of the most concerning potential issues with tile showers is leaks. Improper installation or deterioration over time can lead to water seeping behind the tile, causing major damage to your bathroom structure.  The nightmare scenario involves rotting subflooring, mold growth behind walls, and potential damage to adjoining rooms.  While waterproof membranes can significantly reduce this risk, leaks can still occur.  The challenge lies in pinpointing the source, often requiring extensive demolition to locate and repair the problem.  This can be a costly and time-consuming ordeal.

2 9

Alternative Solutions

Prefabricated shower systems can offer some peace of mind when it comes to leaks.  These one-piece units are typically constructed from watertight acrylic or fiberglass, eliminating the possibility of water infiltration through grout lines.  Additionally, some prefabricated systems come with a pre-sloped pan, ensuring proper water drainage and minimizing the risk of leaks at the shower base.

3. The Expertise Factor: Finding the Tile Whisperer

A flawless tile shower is a work of art, requiring a skilled and meticulous installer. Unevenly laid tiles, improper grouting techniques, or mistakes in waterproofing can all lead to future problems.  Finding a qualified tile installer is crucial, but it can be a challenge.  Experienced tile setters often command a premium price for their expertise, adding to the overall cost of your project.

3 9

Alternative Solutions

While the expertise of a skilled tile setter is undeniable, prefabricated shower systems offer a more straightforward installation process.  These units often require minimal cutting or customization, making them suitable for DIY enthusiasts with basic plumbing and construction skills.  For a more hands-on approach, consider using larger format tiles, which require less cutting and can be installed more quickly.

4. Maintenance Matters: The Ongoing Commitment

Tile showers, while beautiful, require ongoing maintenance to retain their luster and prevent problems like mold growth. Grout, the bane of many a homeowner’s existence, needs to be resealed periodically. The frequency depends on factors like the type of grout used, ventilation in the bathroom, and overall shower usage.  Additionally, the type of tile can influence cleaning requirements.  Some tiles require specific cleaning products and techniques to avoid dulling or etching the surface. Skipping these maintenance tasks can lead to a prematurely dingy and potentially moldy shower, negating the initial investment in aesthetics.

4 8

Alternative Solutions

Solid surface shower wall materials like acrylic or fiberglass offer a significant advantage when it comes to maintenance.  These non-porous surfaces are easy to clean with a simple non-abrasive cleaner and a damp cloth.  Unlike grout, they do not require resealing, saving you time and effort in the long run.  Choosing a shower pan material with a slip-resistant texture can also minimize the need for additional bath mats, which can harbor mold and mildew if not properly cleaned and dried.

5. Slippery When Wet: A Potential Safety Hazard

Some tile materials, particularly smooth or polished finishes, can be quite slippery when wet. This poses a significant safety hazard, especially for elderly or young users, increasing the risk of slips and falls.  While adding textured tiles or bath mats can help improve traction, these introduce additional cleaning considerations. Textured tiles can be more difficult to clean, and bath mats require regular washing and drying to prevent mold growth.

5 9

Alternative Solutions

Consider incorporating textured tiles specifically in the shower floor area to enhance slip resistance. Opt for tiles with a matte or honed finish for a less slippery surface compared to high-gloss options.  If you choose to use bath mats, select quick-drying materials like bamboo or microfiber and ensure proper ventilation in the bathroom to prevent moisture build-up.  Alternatively, prefabricated shower pans often come with built-in textured surfaces that provide excellent slip resistance without the need for additional mats.

6. Time is Money: The Installation Marathon

Tile showers take considerably longer to install compared to prefabricated shower options. This translates to a longer period with your bathroom out of commission, potentially causing inconvenience and disruption to your daily routine.  Additionally, the time-intensive nature of tile installation can lead to higher labor costs associated with skilled tile setters.

6 2

Alternative Solutions

Prefabricated shower systems offer a significant advantage in terms of installation speed.  These units typically come pre-fabricated and can be installed in a matter of days, minimizing downtime in your bathroom.  The modular design often allows for a one-person installation, potentially reducing labor costs compared to hiring a professional tile setter.

7. Design Limitations: Can Tile Tango with Your Dreams?

While tile offers a wide range of design options in terms of color, pattern, and texture, creating custom features like shelves or benches within a tile shower can be complex and expensive.  Custom tilework for niches or shelves requires meticulous planning and skilled craftsmanship, adding to the overall cost and installation time.


Alternative Solutions

Prefabricated shower systems often come with pre-molded shelves, benches, and cubbyholes, eliminating the need for custom tilework. These built-in features offer functionality without sacrificing aesthetics and can be a budget-friendly option compared to custom tile designs.  Additionally, some prefabricated systems offer a variety of design styles, from sleek and modern to classic and traditional, allowing you to achieve the desired look without compromising on functionality.

8. Cold and Hard: A Sensory Consideration

Tile can feel cold underfoot, especially during the colder months. This can be a significant drawback for some users, particularly in climates with colder winters.  While adding radiant floor heating can help alleviate this issue, it adds to the installation cost and complexity of the project.


Alternative Solutions

Consider using a prefabricated shower pan made from a warm-to-the-touch material like acrylic or composite resin. These materials offer a more comfortable showering experience compared to traditional ceramic or stone tile.  Additionally, explore options for installing a programmable thermostat for your radiant floor heating system, allowing you to adjust the temperature for optimal comfort without incurring additional energy costs year-round.

9. Not Budget-Friendly: Counting the Cost of Beauty

High-quality tile, waterproof membranes, and skilled labor make tile showers a relatively expensive bathroom renovation option.  The initial investment can be significant, and unexpected issues during installation can lead to additional costs.

dollars 499481 1280

Alternative Solutions

Prefabricated shower systems offer a more budget-friendly alternative to custom tile showers.  These units come in various price points depending on size, features, and material quality.  The all-inclusive nature of prefabricated systems often includes the shower pan, walls, and sometimes even hardware, simplifying the budgeting process and potentially reducing overall costs.

The Final Splash: Weighing Your Options

Tile showers boast undeniable beauty and classic appeal. They offer a vast canvas for your design vision and can add significant value to your home. However, the drawbacks like mold potential, maintenance needs, and installation challenges can be significant factors to consider. 

Carefully weigh these downsides against your priorities and budget to determine if a tile shower is truly the best option for your dream bathroom.  Explore alternative materials like fiberglass or acrylic panels, which can offer a quicker installation, easier maintenance, and a more budget-friendly price tag.

Remember, the perfect shower should be beautiful, functional, and low-maintenance. Choose the option that best fits your lifestyle, design preferences, and budget.  With careful consideration, you can create a shower space that not only complements your bathroom but also provides years of enjoyment and functionality.


Leave a Reply