The Rev-A-Shelf RV-35-LID-17-1 review centers on a simple replacement part: a silver plastic lid for compatible 35-quart pullout waste containers.
It is aimed at buyers who already have the matching Rev-A-Shelf system and need a concealed, flip-top cover rather than a complete trash bin.
Rev-A-Shelf Review Summary
The Rev-A-Shelf RV-35-LID-17-1 makes sense when the rest of a 35-quart Rev-A-Shelf pullout waste setup is still useful but its lid needs replacing.
The lid is designed to cover the container, attach to the pullout trash can, and help keep odors contained; that gives a cabinet-mounted waste system a cleaner, more finished appearance than an uncovered bin.
It suits kitchen and bathroom cabinet installations, as well as owners of the brand’s compatible 35-quart waste containers.
This is a replacement accessory, not a complete waste-management solution.
The listing specifies that the waste containers are sold separately, so shoppers should confirm that they own a compatible Rev-A-Shelf 35-quart container before ordering.
The key buying decision is fit, not feature count.
Review Scorecard
| Category | Editorial score | Buyer-focused rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Compatibility clarity | 9/10 | Explicitly intended for Rev-A-Shelf 35-quart waste containers. |
| Odor-covering design | 8/10 | The flip-top lid is designed to hold odors in securely. |
| Cabinet integration | 8/10 | Conceals trash inside a pullout kitchen or bathroom cabinet. |
| Dimensions | 8/10 | The supplied 14 x 10.25 x 0.89-inch dimensions aid fit checks. |
| Material choice | 7/10 | Injection-molded polymer is practical and intended for durability. |
| Installation | 8/10 | The lid is designed to affix easily to the pullout trash can. |
| Value as a replacement | 8/10 | Replaces the specific lid without requiring a new full container, provided compatibility is confirmed. |
Key Features and Specifications of Rev-A-Shelf
The RV-35-LID-17-1 is a replacement plastic trash bin lid only.
Its most important specification is compatibility with Rev-A-Shelf 35-quart waste containers.
That makes the model number more useful than a broad search for an under-sink trash-can lid: the accessory is designed around a particular pullout system and capacity.
The supplied dimensions are 14 inches wide by 10.25 inches deep by 0.89 inches high.
Those measurements can help an owner compare the lid with the cabinet opening and existing container, although they do not replace checking the exact container model and attachment points.
The lid is silver, a neutral finish intended to coordinate with the associated waste-container setup.
The lid uses injection-molded polymer plastic.
According to the listing, that material is selected for durability, while the flip-top construction is intended to keep odors contained and improve freshness.
In practical terms, the design addresses two common reasons for adding a lid inside a cabinet: keeping waste visually concealed and reducing the spread of odor around the cabinet area.
Installation is presented as straightforward: the lid easily affixes to the pullout trash can.
The package includes one silver 35-quart waste-container lid.
It does not include a waste container, and the listing specifically says those containers are sold separately.
Do not treat this as a standalone under-sink trash can.
Pros and Cons of Rev-A-Shelf
Pros
- Purpose-built replacement: It is designed for Rev-A-Shelf 35-quart pullout waste containers rather than being a vague universal accessory.
- Concealed waste: A lid keeps the contents out of sight inside a kitchen or bathroom cabinet.
- Flip-top odor control: The listed design is intended to hold odors in securely.
- Compact profile: At 0.89 inches high, the lid is a relatively low-profile component for a pullout cabinet system.
- Simple installation concept: The lid is designed to affix to the existing pullout trash can.
- Durable polymer construction: Injection-molded plastic is a sensible material for a replaceable cabinet accessory.
Cons
- Limited compatibility: Its value depends on owning the matching Rev-A-Shelf 35-quart container.
- Lid only: Buyers needing a complete bin, frame, or pullout mechanism will need additional components.
- No supplied container: The waste container is sold separately, so the product cannot complete a new installation by itself.
- Fit still needs checking: The dimensions are helpful, but owners should verify their specific Rev-A-Shelf setup before purchase.
- Plastic construction: Buyers seeking a metal lid or a different finish may prefer another replacement option.
Who Should Buy Rev-A-Shelf?
Buy this lid if you already use a Rev-A-Shelf 35-quart pullout waste container and need its cover replaced or added.
It is also a sensible choice for a cabinet organizer that has the compatible container but wants a more concealed, orderly waste area.
The flip-top design is particularly relevant when odor control and keeping trash hidden are priorities.
It may fit a kitchen base cabinet or bathroom cabinet application where the existing Rev-A-Shelf pullout hardware is already installed.
The low listed height and defined width and depth make it practical to compare against the current setup before ordering.
Skip it if you do not own a compatible 35-quart Rev-A-Shelf waste container.
It is not the right purchase for someone starting from zero and expecting a complete pullout trash-can kit.
It is also a poor match for buyers who need a lid for a different brand, a different capacity, or a universal free-standing bin.
How the Rev-A-Shelf Lid Works in a Cabinet Waste System
Concealment inside the cabinet
The lid’s primary job is to cover the waste container while the bin remains in its pullout cabinet system.
That creates a tidier visual barrier than leaving the trash open inside the cabinet.
Flip-top access
The flip-top format is intended to preserve convenient access while covering the opening when closed.
This is a useful compromise for a frequently used kitchen or bathroom waste container.
Odor containment
The manufacturer’s listing says the lid holds odors in securely.
That makes the cover more than a cosmetic replacement, although results will depend on how the container is used and how promptly waste is removed.
Replacement-first design
Because the product includes one lid and not the container, it is best understood as a maintenance or completion part.
Confirm the existing container and attachment arrangement before treating the dimensions as a guarantee of fit.
Alternatives to Rev-A-Shelf
If you need a complete pullout waste solution, search Amazon for a Rev-A-Shelf 35-quart waste container system.
This is the closest route for buyers who have the cabinet space but do not yet have the compatible container and hardware.
For a different replacement ecosystem, compare simplehuman under-cabinet trash can systems.
These are worth considering when you are replacing the entire setup and do not need to preserve Rev-A-Shelf compatibility.
Buyers who want a broader range of cabinet-organizing components can also review Blum pull-out waste bins.
A complete alternative may be more appropriate than a lid-only accessory when the existing container or pullout mechanism is worn out.
Is Rev-A-Shelf Worth It?
The Rev-A-Shelf RV-35-LID-17-1 is worth considering when the compatibility match is certain and the goal is to replace a lid without replacing an entire 35-quart pullout waste setup.
Its silver injection-molded polymer construction, flip-top design, compact listed dimensions, and easy-attachment approach address the practical needs of a concealed cabinet bin.
The product is not worth choosing as a standalone trash can because it includes only one lid and requires a compatible Rev-A-Shelf container.
If your existing container is the matching 35-quart model, this is a focused, sensible replacement; if not, choose a complete or correctly matched waste system instead.